The WHO Secretariat held a global, web-based public hearing between 1 September and 3 October 2008 to obtain inputs on the first draft of the WHO code of practice from as wide a group of stakeholders as possible. Member States, national institutions, health professional organisations, nongovernmental organisations, academic institutions, international organisations and other stakeholders submitted more than 90 contributions to the public hearings. Some expressed the view that Article 4 should be revised to provide greater emphasis on the legal responsibilities of health personnel to source and destination countries, such as those to protect the public health interest. Others felt that Article 4 should recommend that states prohibit all active recruitment of health personnel from countries experiencing a health workforce crisis.
Human Resources
Ugandan radiography, medical, nursing, dentistry and pharmacy students are sent to community health facilities where they are expected to participate in community services and other primary healthcare activities for training (COBES). This study was designed to obtain the opinions of radiography teachers and students of the significance and relevance of this community-based training to radiography training. Both students and teachers (91.4%) affirmed the community training to be significant and relevant to radiography training. In total, 71.4% of the students had participated in X-ray services and 39.2% in ultrasound services during COBES; and 68.6% of the students reported the need to be better prepared for the COBES training. They confirmed community-based training to be relevant to Ugandan radiography training.
This study systematically reviewed and consolidated existing evidence of the impact of financial and non-financial incentives on the motivation and retention of health workers. Four literature databases were searched, as well as grey literature studies and informational papers. Twenty qualitative and quantitative studies were selected. There was some evidence to suggest that the use of initiatives to improve motivation had been effective in helping retention. While motivational factors are undoubtedly country specific, financial incentives, career development and management issues are core factors. Nevertheless, financial incentives alone are not enough to motivate health workers. Workplace recognition and adequate resources and infrastructure can also improve morale significantly.
The main objective of this study was to evaluate acceptability and feasibility of reinforcing the role of traditional birth attendants (TBAs) in family and child health services through their participation in prevention of mother-to-child transmission (PMTCT) programmes in Zimbabwe. A community based cross-sectional survey was undertaken in two rural districts through interviews and focus group discussions among women who delivered at home with a TBA and who had an institutional delivery and TBAs. More than 85% of women agreed that TBAs could participate in all activities related to a PMTCT programme with the exception of performing a blood test for HIV. There is a need to reinforce the knowledge of TBAs on MTCT prevention measures and better integrate them into the health system.
Underlining the Alliance vision that 'All people everywhere will have access to a skilled, motivated and supported health worker, within a robust health system', the strategic directions and priorities 2009-2011 confirmed the two main objectives within which the Alliance operates: to enable country leadership in national planning and management to improve the human resources for health (HRH) situation and respond to shortages of skilled and motivated health workers; and to address global policy challenges through evidence-informed actions to tackle trans-national problems in areas such as insufficient and inefficient use of resources, fiscal restraints on health sector spending, migration, priority research and cooperation among all stakeholders.
On 2 December, the first meeting of the enlarged Health Cluster was held at the WHO office in Harare. Afterwards, a working group met with the Ministry of Health and Child Welfare (MoHCW) to work out details of a plan to disburse a £500,000 grant from the UK Department for Development Funding DFID to attract health workers back to their posts. This money could be used to kick-start the planned incentive scheme for health workers to be launched in January 2009. Immediate aims include ensuring effective coordination among all health partners providing cholera-related interventions; increasing capacity to provide more clean drinking water in health facilities; strengthening disease reporting, monitoring and assessment under WHO leadership; and procuring more supplies. This will be followed by longer-term support for the health sector’s revitalisation.
Global Policy Advisory Council members have reviewed and responded to the WHO Draft Code of Practice and had a number of recommendations to make. They believe the Code needs to reflect further on World Health Assembly Resolutions 57.19 and 58.17 and to focus more strongly on mitigating the adverse effects of health personnel migration and its negative impact on health systems in developing countries. A strong preamble is needed to appropriately inform the rationale, context and vision underlying the accompanying articles. The current Code pays much attention to the role of member states generally, but the specific roles of source and destination countries, health workers, recruiters/ employers and other relevant stakeholders require further elaboration. There was wide, though not unanimous, agreement that the principle of shared responsibility is paramount: states that are global employers must help support their source countries’ local health workforce. Clear implementation guidelines are lacking, specifically about how and what information must be collected. Developing countries will need technical and capacity-related assistance, otherwise they will not be able to pay the costs of implementing the Code.
This article profiles three leaders who have made a significance difference in the HR situation in their countries. By taking a comprehensive approach and working in partnership with stakeholders, these leaders demonstrate that strengthening health workforce planning, management, and training can have a positive effect on the performance of the health sector. Three profiles are presented, from Afghanistan, South Africa and southern Sudan, revealing common approaches and leadership traits while demonstrating the specificity of local contexts. In the South African profile, Dr. Mahlathi, Deputy Director General of Human Resources for South Africa's national Department of Health (DOH) is discussed. South Africa will need a multisectoral approach, with strong health management and leadership and additional human and financial resources to help meet the needs of its citizens.
The Global Health Workforce Alliance (GHWA) has welcomed the pledges of commitment expressed at the United Nations High Level Meeting on the Millennium Development Goals and surrounding events that place resolving the health workforce crisis at the centre of ensuring progress on improving maternal and child health and addressing killer diseases such as malaria. Significant financial commitments were made to address the health workforce as part of the drive to move closer to the achievement of Millennium Development Goals 4 and 5 on reducing maternal and child mortality. Commitments included a pledge of £450 million from the UK over the next three years to support national health plans, incorporating training more nurses, midwives and doctors in eight of the poorest countries.
African leaders lack the foresight and political will required to ensure sustainable health development, financing and universal primary health care. By underlining the effects of institutional under-funding and the brain drain, the author contends that policy neglect is the equivalent of ‘institutional manslaughter’. Africa’s critical health workforce shortage is arguably the most serious obstacle to implementing global and African health frameworks and universal primary health care across the continent and governments must improve health workforce working conditions. The proper, moral and sustainable solution is to ensure that more developed countries invest in training of adequate numbers of their own health workforce, and that less-developed countries demonstrate full political commitment to training and retaining their health workers –with the support of more-developed countries, where necessary.